Python’s Argument Clinic for Property-like Access

in

One of the most common sources of frustration comes from using properties as arguments.

First, let’s start by defining what we mean when we say “property-like access”.In Python, you can define properties that behave like attributes but are actually methods under the hood. This allows for more flexibility in your code as well as better encapsulation of data. For example:

# Defining a class called MyClass
class MyClass:
    # Defining a constructor method that initializes the class with a private variable _x set to 0
    def __init__(self):
        self._x = 0
    
    # Defining a property called x that behaves like an attribute but is actually a method under the hood
    @property
    def x(self):
        # Returns the value of the private variable _x
        return self._x
    
    # Defining a setter method for the property x
    @x.setter
    def x(self, value):
        # Checking if the value passed in is an integer and greater than or equal to 0
        if isinstance(value, int) and value >= 0:
            # If the conditions are met, set the private variable _x to the value passed in
            self._x = value
        
    # ... (other methods can be added here)

In this example, we’ve defined a property called `x`. When you access it using the dot notation (i.e., `obj.x`), Python will call the `x()` method instead of returning an attribute directly. This allows us to add some logic around setting and getting values for our data.

Now, how this can be used as an argument in a function or method. Imagine you have a function that takes two arguments: one is a required `x` value, while the other is an optional `y` value. You want to make sure that both of these values are properties on your class so that they behave like attributes and provide some validation logic when setting them.

Here’s where things get tricky!In Python, you can pass a property as an argument just by using the dot notation (i.e., `obj.x`). However, this can lead to confusion because it looks like we’re passing in an attribute instead of a method call. To avoid any misunderstandings or errors, let’s take a look at how you should properly use properties as arguments!

First, let’s define our function:

# Defining a class called MyClass
class MyClass:
    # ...

    # Defining a method called do_something that takes in two arguments, x and y
    def do_something(self, x, y=None):
        # Checking if the argument y is not None
        if y is not None:
            # Setting the attribute y of the object to the value of y passed in as an argument
            self.y = y  # <-- this line can cause confusion! (This line can be confusing because it looks like we're passing in an attribute instead of a method call)

        # ... (Performing some other operations within the method)

In the above example, we’ve defined a function called `do_something()`. This function takes two arguments: `x` and an optional `y`. If you pass in a value for `y`, it will be assigned to the `y` property on your object. However, this can cause confusion because it looks like we’re passing in an attribute instead of a method call!

To avoid any misunderstandings or errors, let’s modify our function to properly use properties as arguments:

class MyClass:
    # Define a class named MyClass
    
    def do_something(self, x, y=None):
        # Define a method named do_something that takes in two arguments, x and y, with y being optional and set to None by default
        
        if y is not None:
            # Check if y is not None, meaning a value was passed in for y
            
            self.y = y
            # Assign the value of y to the y property of the object
            
        # ...
        
# The purpose of this function is to modify the do_something method to properly use properties as arguments. This is done by checking if a value was passed in for y and then assigning it to the y property of the object. This avoids confusion and errors that may occur if we were to pass in an attribute instead of a method call.

In the above example, we’ve modified our function to use Python’s `getattr()` function instead of directly accessing the `y` property on your object. This ensures that you are calling a method (i.e., `self.y`) and not passing in an attribute as an argument!

Remember: always use the dot notation when accessing properties on your objects, but be careful when passing them as arguments to functions or methods!

SICORPS